Your Home Is Not As Secure As You Think

7 min read
Burglar Breakingin

A lot of thought, resources and angst is available for the topic of “safety” or “security.” And there is a whole career field whose sole purpose is to get inside any of our homes or cars at any time. We’re talking about locksmiths, of course (also: ninjas), and it’s not exactly a freaky profession. Unless you really, really think about it. And we did. Lord only knows why. Consider…

Beware Of Fake Locksmiths

A New York Times article pointed out that fraudulent locksmiths dominate the paid search results for “locksmith” in many American cities. They advertise 24-hour availability and crazy-low prices, sometimes as little as $15.00. But when they arrive, they inevitably wind up claiming the lock is too complicated, cut through it, and charge hundreds of dollars for the favor.

Scam locksmithing is a cottage industry, where companies will offer to sponsor visas for fresh-faced, morally flexible young men, as long as they don’t mind a little borderline extortion. There are hundreds of these companies. So how can you avoid getting scammed? A few tips:

  1. Always try to find a local company. A lot of scammers use 1-800 numbers and don’t have a local shop at the address provided.
  2. Always ask for their license number. You can also visit the website to find an Associated Locksmiths of America registered locksmith based on your zip code. If they are registered with ALOA, they are legit.
  3. Keep better track of your keys.

Harvey added that anyone willing to give you a “guaranteed” price over the phone is probably scamming. “Any one of a hundred factors might take a 10-minute job and change it into a 60-minute job. Oh, you forgot to tell the guy over the phone that you’d tried to jimmy the lock with a screwdriver? Well, the $29.00 price we provided is now invalid. Oh, you didn’t know this door has stupidly complicated lock cylinders? That’s fine, but the price has changed … if they say, ‘Guaranteed to be $29, including labor,’ you’re going to have a bad time when they arrive.”

Anybody Can Replicate Your Keys Using A Picture

Home Key

We have two-factor authentication on our email accounts, we avoid sharing too much on social media, we can’t even trust our TVs these days. What you’ve probably never worried about is somebody taking a picture of your keys. What could anyone do with a picture?

Says one locksmith: “I can make most any key from a photo, without any key cutting machinery or key blanks. I’ve prototyped the highest-security keys in the world in free 3D modeling software, printed them with online print and post services, and had spare plastic keys delivered to my door and operating sample cylinders, all without complicated measuring tools …”

“Copying a high-tech key from a blurry cellphone picture” sounds like the kind of thing only a movie super-thief could do. It’s actually simple. One company used to make a new house key, same-day, from a picture. Now they’re closed to the public “to focus on our enterprise customers.” They don’t explicitly deny that sex criminals were snapping photos of you getting your keys out in a parking lot, then using them to break into your house, so we are forced to assume that’s exactly what happened. Either way, it boils down to, “It’s so easy to copy your keys, no criminal would even bother to use us.”

No Lock Is As Secure As You’d Think

Secure Lock

You might expect professional locksmiths to be bullish on the ability of a solid lock to protect your home and Beanie Baby collection. But a career of dealing with the aftermath of break-ins has shown them how easy it is to bypass a lock. “You look for the removable air conditioner in the window or the insecure patio glass door… Only once have I been called to install security fasteners on an air-conditioned unit. Turns out a previous tenant wanted back in, so they unscrewed the A/C unit and climbed in through the hole.”

Engaging that deadbolt feels secure, but it’s about as safe as taking a spoon to a gunfight. “You can encase your house in six feet of concrete, and I’ll still get in if I want to. It just takes time.” One locksmith explains that “99 percent of people’s locks are garbage. Looking out my window, I can see 15 houses that wouldn’t take me longer than 15 seconds each to gain entry to.” He’s not talking about picking those locks, cat-burglar-like. He’s talking about breaking through them. Over his entire career, he “saw about 10-15 confirmed cases of lock destruction in forced entry, and one confirmed case of lock-picking.” He’s also picked up on some neat tricks for breaking and entering: “A group of kids buy a $2 bottle of syrup, pour it all over your living-area window pane, [then] when they smashed the pane, it doesn’t make the classic window break sound, it’s rather quiet and subdued.”

Then there’s lock-bumping: “How to bump locks is easy to find on the internet, as well as how to make the bump key to be able to bump the lock open. It’s all readily available to criminals via YouTube or other sites, including Reedit.” A company named Rift Recon sells bump keys and other equipment to “red teams” – people who are hired to break into businesses in order to test their security.

No lock is safe. Not even the locks in prison isolation cells. Locksmiths have had to repair those: “I was asked to repair one of the interconnecting doors between the primary cell and a shower/toilet area. I knew these doors, massive 7×4 slabs of steel-sheeted through-bolted wooden doors with full-length stainless steel anti-hang piano hinges. One door is a struggle for two persons to move.” But as you can guess, “one inmate had gone ballistic and torn the seven-foot hinge out of the door, broken the steel closer arm, picked it up and used it as a battering ram on the cell door.”

Sliding that little chain thingy into the notch doesn’t feel so secure anymore, does it?

Criminals Can Call Locksmiths Too


Sure, some criminals might use sites like Rift Recon or spend hours learning how to pick locks. Most cut to the chase and call a locksmith themselves. One tells of a customer who wanted help getting into someone’s car. “Customer only gave a first name until I required a surname. The car was a 10-year-old pickup, with scratches and tears all over the inside window of the driver’s door, window sill ripped off. Standard procedure is to work on the passenger door, so any damage is not related to us. I scoped out the interior and couldn’t see the keys, so I called the guy and he said they’d be under the seat. No problem, I opened the passenger door and went looking. No keys. I called the customer back to find out what the deal was, and said [I’d] need some more concrete proof that he owned the vehicle. His voice started getting sketchy. He said fine, he’d visit the workshop that afternoon with paperwork. Never did see him.”

Here’s an even sketchier experience with this kind of “customer.” Locksmith says, “Opened a home for a guy once who had proper ID … As usual when I go to a home lockout, I asked to see proof of ID. The husband’s license had the address on it, so I let him in. When the police showed up, I understood what was happening. The wife went out of town earlier in the day, which the husband knew, since he was tracking her cell phone. The wife had the locks changed so he could not get into the home. He wanted his Porsche that was in the garage. The Porsche was in the divorce proceedings, so he was not to move it via a court ruling.”

A Locksmith Might Face Cops

To an outside observer, a working locksmith doesn’t look much different than a working burglar. That’s natural; the skills of a locksmith translate directly to burglary. So good locksmiths spend a lot of time vetting their new employees. In Tennessee, “We have to get ID numbers for any lockouts we do, as well as re-keying houses and making keys to cars we also have to match the ID to the name on the title to make sure that person is allowed to get keys for the vehicle/house.”

Good locksmiths are always worried about unwittingly helping to commit a crime. “The worst job I had to refuse was pretty recent. A lady locked herself out of a house an hour and a half away from us, but she had been in process of selling her house and it fell through, and she didn’t have the paperwork with her to prove she was the owner of the house – no recent mail to the house, and she had an out-of-state ID. We had to turn her down because she had no proof at 10 o’clock at night. I felt bad that I couldn’t help her get back in the house, but the law is the law. And if we don’t follow it, we can lose our license or get sued.”

But upstanding locksmiths run afoul of law enforcement sometimes. One had a cop pull a gun on him once while trying to get into a foreclosed home on behalf of the bank that owned it. “I tried the front door, then walked around to the back door. I’m sure a neighbor saw me trying to get into the home and called 911. When I came back round the house, I was carrying my tools and the deputy walking up mistook my cordless drill as a gun and drew his gun. I dropped the drill, then went to clean out my pants.”